The Worst Case Isn't as Bad as the Fear of It

← All Posts

I've watched a kid blow a lead he should have held because he was more afraid of blowing it than he was focused on getting the next out. He wasn't beat by the hitter in the box. He was beat by a version of the game that hadn't happened yet, playing on a loop in his head. Hope is not a strategy. The Stoics figured that out a long time before anybody put it on a poster, and they built an actual practice around it instead.

A Practice for Guys Who Hate Surprises

The Stoics called it premeditatio malorum. The premeditation of evils. Before something important, you deliberately imagine what could go wrong. Not to spiral into anxiety about it. To strip the worst case of its power over you before it gets the chance. Most of the things we're afraid of lose most of their terror the moment we actually look directly at them instead of away from them.

That's the whole move. You're not hoping the bad outcome never shows up. You're deciding, ahead of time, exactly what you'll do if it does. The fear loses its grip the second it stops being a vague shape in the dark and starts being a problem you already have an answer for.

Twenty-Two Years of Learning What Happens When You Don't Prepare for It

I spent 22 years in environments where the cost of being surprised by a bad outcome was real, not theoretical. The people who performed best under pressure were almost never the most talented in the room. They were the ones who had already thought through what could go wrong and decided in advance how they would respond. When the moment actually came, they weren't panicking. They were just executing a plan they'd already made.

The Kid Who Already Lost the Game in His Head

Take a closer getting ready to take the mound in the ninth with a one run lead. The way to get him ready isn't to tell him not to think about blowing it. It's to let him think about it on purpose, before he ever throws a pitch. Say he gives up a leadoff double. Say the next batter ties it. What does he do next. He throws the next pitch he was going to throw anyway, because the plan for a tied game was decided back in the bullpen, not invented live while his heart rate spikes.

That's the difference between a kid who falls apart after one bad inning and a kid who gets the next three outs anyway. The second kid isn't braver. He just already ran the tape on the worst case and found out he could survive it.

Ask Yourself the Two Questions

You can apply this to anything in your life right now. The hard conversation you've been avoiding. The risk you've been afraid to take. The relationship you're worried about. Ask yourself what the worst realistic outcome actually is. Then ask yourself if you could handle it. Almost always the answer is yes. And once you know you can survive the worst, you stop being paralyzed by the fear of it.

What is something you've been avoiding because of fear? What is the actual worst case scenario, and could you survive it?