A few seasons back I had a kid everybody wanted to clone. Routine ground ball, error, bases loaded, didn't matter. His face never moved. Parents in the stands would point him out to each other between innings. "That's what you want. Ice in his veins."
He wasn't ice. He just didn't care if we won.
Flat Isn't the Same as Disciplined
It took me most of that season to see the difference. He wasn't managing anything. There was nothing underneath to manage. The game was somewhere to be on a Tuesday, not something he was invested in, so losing never touched him any more than a rained-out practice would.
Compare that to a kid I had who cried in the dugout after we blew a playoff game on a throwing error. Visibly wrecked. Couldn't talk about it for ten minutes. That same kid was the first one at the field Monday, working the exact throw that cost us, over and over, until it was automatic.
One of those two players looked calm. The other one actually was. They are not the same thing.
The Stoics Weren't Numb
There's a version of Stoicism going around online that gets this backwards. The idea that being Stoic means not letting anything touch you. Cold, detached, unbothered by everyone and everything.
That's not what the actual Stoics did. Marcus Aurelius wrote with real anguish about where he'd failed as a father and as a leader. Seneca's letters are full of warmth for the people he loved. Epictetus, who'd been enslaved and crippled and had every excuse to go cold on the world, taught with passion for the rest of his life. None of them were indifferent. They cared deeply. They were just disciplined enough not to let the feeling make their decisions for them.
Armor Isn't Strength
When a young man decides the move is to feel nothing, he's not building discipline. He's building armor. And armor is fear dressed up as strength. It looks like control from the outside. From the inside it's usually just a kid who got hurt once and decided caring was the thing that did it to him.
The goal was never to feel less. It's to respond better. To care about the right things for the right reasons, and to hold that care steady even when it would be easier to just shut it off.
So watch which kid you actually have. The one who doesn't react because none of it means anything to him, or the one who feels every bit of it and still shows up Monday to fix what's fixable. Only one of those is building something.
Kyle Loftin is the founder of The Humble Forge and a 22-year military veteran. He coaches young men 18 to 24 who are done drifting and ready to build something that holds.
All coaching activities and content are conducted independently and do not represent the United States military or the Department of Defense. This site uses cookies and Google Analytics to understand how visitors use it.
Learn About Coaching